Do you quarantine?

When you pick up new fish, Do you quarantine?

  • Yes - Always. Would never put a new fish in with my current stock.

    Votes: 3 8.8%
  • Depends on if I have the room.

    Votes: 6 17.6%
  • Depends on who I get the fish from.

    Votes: 15 44.1%
  • About 1/2 the time.

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I never bother because its over rated.

    Votes: 3 8.8%
  • Just don't have the room or time to worry about it.

    Votes: 7 20.6%

  • Total voters
    34

Jumbie

Members
Even though I voted on "Depends on if I have the room" I agree with Richard. A few years I didn’t have any tank(s) dedicated for quarantine and besides up till that point I have had great success without quarantining fish. Well I lost an entire colony of (12) Tropheous "Cape Kachese" because I added 5 Simochromis without quarantining them. I quickly learned to quarantine everything after seeing such a beautiful and really expensive colony of fish die one by one. LOL
 

George

CCA Charter Member and person in charge of the we
I quarantine fish, inverts, AND PLANTS. I am already a nasty old curmudgeon so all I can say is that if you don't quarantine, obviously you don't give two s___s about your fish.

NUFF SAID!!

Guess who non-quaratining dummies.
 

Lively

Members
I never thought about qt for plants.

I didn't used to quarantine - I didn't know better and I never had a problem. When I knew better, I wasn't buying fish - so it didn't matter. When I decided I was going to try my hand at breeding EBJD's - I made sure I had the ability to qt and kept a tank out of the loop for a hospital tank. Added three months to getting the fish to make sure I was ready.

Here is the kicker - I quarantined the EB's for about a month and no sooner did I add a couple of my own fish to that tank - I got stringy poo disease. I doubt it was from my existing fish, none of the other (50 or so) Dempsey's in that tank got sick.

Next time I get fish I'm planning to add to the general population I'll qt for two months.
 
Here is the kicker - I quarantined the EB's for about a month and no sooner did I add a couple of my own fish to that tank - I got stringy poo disease. QUOTE]

Some times no matter how much you QT there might be some disease that shows up when you add the fish to the main tank. Like I said before, I did QT when buying wild salt water fish. I think QT is good for two things:
a) Make sure the fish will survive, especially when coming form the wild. All the handling and transport these fish go through is pretty rough. That is why buying tank raised fish is so much better, they are more hardy fish.
b) Treat any disease/parasite that can be noticed right away i.e. ich, worms, etc, and TRY TO prevent wild diseases form being introduced to a tank. Remember, there is no cure all disease/parasite medicine. You have to treat what ever disease your fish is suffering from. If someone knows of one please let me know;).


I never meant to say or make it seem like I don't care about my fish, or to put it in George's words "don't give two s__s about your fish". All I am saying is that tank raised fish don't carry as many bugs as wild fish do. They come from, not always, a clean environment. I have found that tank raised fish don't need too much QTing. If anything, keeping a close eye on them the first 2-3 weeks I think is enough. 99.99% of the time they tend to be very healthy fish.

Example, DQ is selling his fish. I know his fish are healthy and he does regular maintenance in his tank, why would I need to QT?? If DQ were an irresponsible fish keeper than I would QT.

That is my two cents:)

*DQ, I didn't mean to put you on the spot, but I know you are my friend and will not kill me for using you as an example:)*
 
Last edited:

Pat Kelly

CCA Member
Just remember that even if you Quarantine you can still introduce things. A fish can be a carrier without showing signs.

I quarantined a female fish that I picked up at one of the meetings. I kept her by herself for a month. Regular water changes etc.
I put her in with the male and a breeding group of peacocks and within
1 week all that was left was the male I got her for. 8 fish dead.
Including my one Lwanda group.
 

longstocking

Members
That is why I don't quaranteen if they come from those 3 people...

They dont' always show signs.... infact 99% of the time they won't untill you put them into the new tank with other fish.

Fish from a fish store... sfish from an auction... or fish from any other hobbyists.... QUARANTEEN
 

YSS

Members
This is what a lot of discus people do. After a QT period, they put a fish from the main tank to the QT tank to see what happens. If they are both fine, then the new fish go in the main tank, if not, I don't know what they do. I don't do that. I never really QT my fish because I generally buy fish from a trusted source like Sarah. :) And since I never buy anything but really really healthy looking fish under good care, I selected I never QT my fish.
 

Pat Kelly

CCA Member
This is what a lot of discus people do. After a QT period, they put a fish from the main tank to the QT tank to see what happens. If they are both fine, then the new fish go in the main tank, if not, I don't know what they do. QUOTE]

Hmm. Never thought of that one.
 

longstocking

Members
Yun that is actually the best idea I have heard in long time...

Next time with expensive fish... i'm going to do that ! IE Petrochromis... They are large fish that I just don't have the room to quaranteen... I don't think anyone really does with them :lol:
 
Top