WOW, I'm really sorry, somehow, when I go from email to post it doesn't show me the entire entry, wtf?....:unsure:
Anyway, your dosing the water column EI, which means ur keeping up with your wc's, adding co2, T5 lighting, extra circulation. Nice set up if you ask me.
"Petsmart" plants, in my experience, they are a crap shoot. Many come in emersed form (wisteria def does). I've found much better stems purchasing from other hobbiests off of APC, GWAPA or TPT.
BBA sucks, limiting my lighting has always killed it off in my tanks. Four T5's on any tank is a lot of light, I've cut my 75g hi tech down to 2 T5 bulbs raised 9" above the waters edge. Brown algae, wipe as much as you can off leaves before a wc, and buy a few oto's and/or nerites from Rachel. TDS shouldn't be a factor, but could be if it's high in your tap water and your dosing micro's.
A tank set up a year it shouldn't be your substrate, did I miss that info also, what is the substrate on the tank? Even my 7 month old Tangy tank with PFS does well with root tabs.