Anyone ever try a pond filter for large tanks?

I have had fish tanks for years, but only recently started getting into the bigger ones. I have a 150 gallon with an Eheim 2028 on it that's just not getting it done. Does anybody have any good filter suggestions for larger tanks. Does anyone use pond filters which seem to be less expensive or are wet/dry filters the way to go for large tanks. I could use some advice. Thanks in advance.
Matt
 

dogofwar

CCA Members
I make dump filters for all of my big tanks (and small ones too). Basically a DIY sump (rubbermaid) on top of the tank...fed by a pump in the tank...and water dumps back into the tank via gravity (holes in the bottom of the rubbermaid).

Because you're not losing much head (from pumping water up several feet as with a traditional, under-the-tank sump) and because the dropping of the water via gravity moves a lot of water, you can get away with using a smaller pump. You also don't need a drilled tank.

You can also feed the dump filter with your canister. Basically set the return into the dump filter...and voila!

I'm filtering a heavily stocked 180 with an FX5 that feeds an 18g dump filter (filled with bio balls). That's it (other than a couple of small air-fed filters).

I'm filtering a 150g with a pond sponge filter...and a 350gph pump feeding a dump filter.

It's energy efficient, works great and easy to clean. The only drawback is that it's not exactly something that I'd want in my living room (unless I used I nice rubbermaid or concealed it under a canopy)...or my bedroom (sound of falling water)...

Matt
 

dustin

Members
I'd go with a sump all the way. You can't beat them IMO. Byt if you choose to go the canister route, I'd suggest the eheim 2250 or equivalent. I use one and for a canister you honestly can't go wrong. IMO they blow any fx5 or any other comparable canister outta the water. And yes I've used the fx5's and didn't care for them compared to the eheims. Hands down. But like I said, I'd go sump. Just my 2 cents.
 
Top